Suggested Maximum Rate Schedules Effective January 1, 2020
Approved by the American Council on Gift Annuities on November 8, 2019
As part of a continuous monitoring process, the American Council on Gift Annuities (ACGA) Board of Directors held a meeting on November 8, 2019 and reviewed the current assumptions inherent in our gift annuity rate schedules. The ACGA regularly reviews the financial and actuarial assumptions behind its suggested maximum gift annuity rates to ensure they are fiscally responsible for charities. The Board approved a decrease in the suggested maximum payout rates for charitable gift annuities. The rates will be decreasing by 0.40% to 0.50% for donor ages when a majority of annuity contracts are written. These new rates will become effective on January 1, 2020.
Generally speaking, the ACGA's suggested maximum rates are designed to produce a target gift for charity at the conclusion of the contract equal to 50% of the funds contributed for the annuity. The rates are further predicated on the following:
- An annuitant mortality assumption equal to a 50/50 blended of male and female mortality under the 2012 Individual Annuity Reserving Table (the 2012 IAR)
- A gross investment return expectation of 4.25% (which is down from the previous return assumption of 4.75%) per year on the charity's gift annuity funds
- An expense assumption of 1% per year.
The rate schedule published below became effective on January 1, 2020. The full paper on the new ACGA rates effective January 1, 2020 is now available in an electronic format free of charge to logged in ACGA members in our online store. Non-members may purchase a copy of the full rates paper in our online store for $75.
For more detailed information about gift annuity rates and the assumptions that underlie them, view our full rates reports, download the rates tables and access the rates brochure here.
- Single Life - ACGA Suggested Gift Annuity Rates
- Two Lives - ACGA Suggested Gift Annuity Rates
- Procedure for Calculating Suggested Deferred Gift Annuity Rates
- Note to Charities Issuing Deferred Gift Annuities in New York and New Jersey
Following is a summary of the major assumptions on which the suggested rates are based.
Target Residuum. Since 1955 the ACGA has targeted a residuum (the amount realized by the charity upon termination of an annuity) of 50% of the original contribution for the gift annuity. The new rate schedules retain the 50% target residuum, and continue the requirement first applied for the July 2011 rate schedules that the present value (PV) of the residuum be at least 20% of the original contribution for the annuity.
The 20% minimum PV requirement has the effect of reducing rates for annuitants age 59 and under. It is designed to help charities realize a minimum value from gifts whose residua will not be realized for many years. Rates for younger annuitants (ages 5 to 37 and 39) were reduced as necessary to comply with the 10% minimum charitable deduction required under IRC Sec. 514 (c)(5)(A) using the 1.8% CFMR for October 2019. Particularly in low interest rate environments, charities should perform their own deduction calculations and lower their annuity rates if necessary to meet the 10% minimum deduction requirement.
Mortality Assumptions. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) has recommended the use of a new mortality table for commercial and gift annuities issued after January 1, 2015. Known as the 2012 Individual Annuity Reserving Table (2012 IAR), the new table is designed to reflect annuitant mortality more accurately over time. ACGA commissioned a study by The Korn Ferry Hay Group in December 2014 to determine what set of assumptions provided the best “fit” for the 2012 IAR with the ACGA Gift Annuitant Mortality Study completed in 2010. The Korn Ferry Hay Group determined the new “best fit” assumption was a 50-50 blend of the 2012 IAR male and female mortality with no age setback. (See further discussion below.)
Expense Assumption. Annual expenses for investment and administration are assumed to be 1.0% of the fair market value of gift annuity reserves.
Investment Return Assumption. The gross annual expected return on immediate payment and deferred payment gift annuity reserves is 4.25%. Both immediate and deferred payment annuity calculations use a net compounding rate of 3.25% (4.25% minus 1% assumed annual expenses).
Payment Assumption. Annual payments are made in quarterly installments at the end of each period.
The rates for the oldest ages are somewhat lower than the rates that would follow from the above assumptions. Single life rates are capped at 9.0% for annuitants age 90 and above. Single life rates for annuitants between ages 81 and 89 are graduated downward from the rate cap. Two life rates are capped at 8.8% for annuitants above 90 and are graduated downward in a similar way.
Additional Assumption for Deferred Gift Annuities
The annual compound interest rate credited during the deferral period for deferred payment gift annuities is 3.25% (the same investment return assumption as for immediate payment gift annuities after subtracting the 1.0% expense assumption). In other words, each dollar contributed for a deferred gift annuity is presumed to grow at an annual compound interest rate of 3.25% between the date of contribution and the annuity starting date.
If payments will be made at the end of the period, which is usually the case, the annuity starting date would be at the beginning of the first period for which a payment is made. For example, if payments will be made quarterly, and the first payment will be made on September 30, 2028, the annuity starting date would be July 1, 2028. If payments will be made semi-annually, the annuity starting date in this case would be April 1, 2028.
Assuming that the annuitant would be nearest age 65 on the annuity starting date, and that the period between the contribution date and the annuity starting date is 10.25 years, the compound interest factor would be 1.032510.25or 1.387948. To determine the deferred gift annuity rate, this factor is multiplied by the immediate gift annuity rate, now in effect, for the nearest age of the annuitant at the time payments begin. In this example, the deferred gift annuity rate would be 1.387948 times 4.7%, or 6.5% (rounded to the nearest tenth of a percent).
The 3.25% compounding rate applies to the entire compounding period, whatever its length. (At times in the past, the compounding rate for periods in excess of 20 years was less than the compounding rate for the first 20 years of the deferral period.)
Historically, it has sometimes been necessary to apply a slightly lower compounding rate when the deferral period is relatively long in order not to exceed the maximum allowable deferred gift annuity rates allowed by the states of New York and New Jersey. However, this has not been the case for many years.
- The rates are for ages at the nearest birthday.
- For immediate gift annuities, these rates will result in a charitable deduction of more than 10% if the CFMR is 1.8% or higher, whatever the payment frequency. If the CFMR is less than 1.8%, the deduction will be less than 10% when annuitants are below certain ages.
- For deferred gift annuities with longer deferral periods, the rates may not pass the 10% test when the CFMR is low.
- To avoid adverse tax consequences, the charity should reduce the gift annuity rate to whatever level is necessary to generate a charitable deduction in excess of 10%.
|Younger Age||Older Age||Rate||Younger Age||Older Age||Rate|
Approved by the American Council on Gift Annuities--Effective January 1, 2020 (New York & New Jersey see note below)
- Determine the annuity starting date, which is:
- One year before the first payment, if payments are made annually.
- Six months before the first payment, if payments are made semi-annually.
- Three months before the first payment, if payments are made quarterly.
- One month before the first payment, if payments are made monthly.
- Determine the number of whole and fractional years from the date of the contribution to the annuity starting date (the deferral period). Express the fractional year to four decimal places.
- For a deferral period of any length, use the following formula to determine the compound interest factor:
- F = 1.0325 d, where
- F is the compound interest factor and
- d is the deferral period
Example: If the period between the contribution date and the annuity starting date is 10.25 years, the compound interest factor would be 1.032510.25 = 1.387948
- Multiply the compound interest factor (F) by the immediate gift annuity rate for the nearest age or ages of a person or persons at the annuity starting date.
Example: If the sole annuitant will be nearest age 65 on the annuity starting date and the compound interest factor is 1.387948, the deferred gift annuity rate would be 1.387948 times 4.7%, or 6.5% (rounded to the nearest tenth of a percent).
- The annuity starting date for purposes of calculating the deferred gift annuity rate will be the same as the annuity starting date for calculating the charitable deduction, if payments are at the end of the period (which is usually the case). This was not true with the pre-July 1, 2001 methodology.
- An annuitant is credited with compound interest for the entire period from the date of contribution to the annuity starting date. Under the pre-July, 2001 methodology, compound interest was credited only for the number of whole years between the two dates.
- Charities issuing deferred gift annuities in New York and New Jersey may need to use a slightly lower compounding rate depending on the deferral period.
Approved by the American Council on Gift Annuities - Effective January 1, 2020
The following compound interest factors during the deferral period noted will satisfy the requirements of New York and New Jersey:
For all deferral periods:
Single-life and two-life annuities, whatever the gender of the annuitants, a compound interest factor of 3.25%.
*New York and New Jersey are the two states known at this time that may require different interest factors for deferred gift annuities with longer deferral periods.